What works in wellbeing: a randomised controlled trial of mindfulness in policing

Randomised Control Trial Status

Completed

Trial Hypothesis

  • Online training in mindfulness will improve wellbeing, life satisfaction, resilience and performance for police officers and staff (primary outcomes) – accept hypothesis.

  • Online training in mindfulness will reduce sick leave, presenteeism and leaveism (secondary outcomes) – accept hypothesis for reducing presenteeism, do not accept hypothesis for sick leave and leaveism.  

  • Bespoke training aimed at police officers (Mindfit Cop) will improve wellbeing, resilience and performance for police officers and staff more effectively than a generic mindfulness intervention (Headspace) – do not accept hypothesis.

  • Mindfulness training is more likely to be effective for people with high levels of job control in terms of how they structure their day and do their tasks – do not accept hypothesis.

Geographical area

UK: Bedfordshire; Cambridgeshire; Hertfordshire; Avon and Somerset; South Wales.

Research Institution / Organisation

College of Policing

In Collaboration With

Bedfordshire Police; Cambridgeshire Constabulary; Hertfordshire Constabulary; Avon and Somerset Constabulary; South Wales Police.

Contact Name

Dr Helen Fitzhugh

Project Start Date

June 2018

Participants - inclusion criteria

Any police officer or staff member within the five forces who was not:

a)  actively using a mindfulness app already, or
b)  receiving talking therapy.

Target Sample Size

1,322 participants (after 15 withdrew).

Study Design

All officers and staff in the five forces were invited to take part in the trial. Those who volunteered were randomly allocated to one of three groups (Headspace, Mindfit Cop or a waiting list). This study was a basic randomised design comparing two treatment groups (mindfulness training) to control.

Interventions

  • Treatment 1:  receives free access to the 'Headspace' app/online course
  • Treatment 2:  receives free access to the 'Mindfit Cop' web app/online course

Outcome Measures

  • Wellbeing - measured using the Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale (7 items)
  • Life Satisfaction – measured using a single item from the Office of National Statistics personal wellbeing questions
  • Resilience - measured using the Brief Resilience Scale (6 items)
  • Work performance - measured using a question from the WHO HPQ survey
  • Presenteeism and leaveism – measured using custom single items for this study.

Date last updated

Wednesday 06 November 2019
Return to Research Map